Scouting for the Pizza Hunters App brought me to Mr Dinos in Montair. As always the case in Montclair, you need to get lucky with Parking. Customer Service was excellent and owner was more than willing to talk about Pizza or anything else for that matter. Just a great local Pizzeria that has been around since the 80s. Pizza was solid, people were great, deserves a return Visit for sure.
Zizou D.
-
July 22, 2023
Awesome food I like the penne vodka they have. If you are at Montclair NJ you need to check it out mmmmm
Mark A. Drexler
-
October 15, 2022
Having a large pie straight out of the oven, I'd expect a somewhat crispier crust, but it was incredibly doughy, the cheese and sauce were flavorful though, but the cheese was oozing everywhere. Feels like it was taken out of the oven too soon. The guy making the pizza gave me strong Uncle Jun' vibes, attitude and thick rimmed glasses and all. Not sure I would be coming back!
James Demaria
-
March 22, 2025
We’ve been coming here for over 15 years. (Well it’s different owners now.) And where the food is ok I find myself saying never again. Myself and son were walking by and smelled pizza. We hadn’t had lunch yet so in we went. I ordered two margarita slices for him. And one square vodka slice for me. $14!!!! More for a credit card purchase. (Still don’t get that.) I almost fell over. I know I know. It’s “speciality” slices. And I know I know. It’s Montclair. And the economy. But come on. That’s nuts. There are other places around where you can get a whole pie for close to the same amount. And the pizza is better. I didn’t want to disappoint my son so I coughed up the money. But. Never. Again.
Tyson Saltwell
-
March 23, 2025
Superb New Jersey pizza by the slice shop. Traditional slice is outstanding and the Sicilian is worth checking out as well. Look forward to trying again when back in town. Great folks running this spot - spoke with Nick who was super friendly and cordial. Highly recommend folks stop by to try a slice.
Chuck Mound
-
February 23, 2022
Scouting for the Pizza Hunters App brought me to Mr Dinos in Montair. As always the case in Montclair, you need to get lucky with Parking. Customer Service was excellent and owner was more than willing to talk about Pizza or anything else for that matter. Just a great local Pizzeria that has been around since the 80s. Pizza was solid, people were great, deserves a return Visit for sure.
Zizou D.
-
July 22, 2023
Awesome food I like the penne vodka they have. If you are at Montclair NJ you need to check it out mmmmm
Mark A. Drexler
-
October 15, 2022
Having a large pie straight out of the oven, I'd expect a somewhat crispier crust, but it was incredibly doughy, the cheese and sauce were flavorful though, but the cheese was oozing everywhere. Feels like it was taken out of the oven too soon. The guy making the pizza gave me strong Uncle Jun' vibes, attitude and thick rimmed glasses and all. Not sure I would be coming back!
James Demaria
-
March 22, 2025
We’ve been coming here for over 15 years. (Well it’s different owners now.) And where the food is ok I find myself saying never again. Myself and son were walking by and smelled pizza. We hadn’t had lunch yet so in we went. I ordered two margarita slices for him. And one square vodka slice for me. $14!!!! More for a credit card purchase. (Still don’t get that.) I almost fell over. I know I know. It’s “speciality” slices. And I know I know. It’s Montclair. And the economy. But come on. That’s nuts. There are other places around where you can get a whole pie for close to the same amount. And the pizza is better. I didn’t want to disappoint my son so I coughed up the money. But. Never. Again.
Tyson Saltwell
-
March 23, 2025
Superb New Jersey pizza by the slice shop. Traditional slice is outstanding and the Sicilian is worth checking out as well. Look forward to trying again when back in town. Great folks running this spot - spoke with Nick who was super friendly and cordial. Highly recommend folks stop by to try a slice.
Chuck Mound
-
February 23, 2022
Scouting for the Pizza Hunters App brought me to Mr Dinos in Montair. As always the case in Montclair, you need to get lucky with Parking. Customer Service was excellent and owner was more than willing to talk about Pizza or anything else for that matter. Just a great local Pizzeria that has been around since the 80s. Pizza was solid, people were great, deserves a return Visit for sure.
<
>
Our Address
119 Watchung Ave, Montclair, NJ 07043, USA
To navigate, press the arrow keys.
Claim Listing: Mr. Dino’s
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
Would you like to see your business listed here for free? Just register, then log in and add your business. Free service is available to all Montclair businesses.
For more information on our listings, advertising, coupons, and mailers, please contact us today!
Scouting for the Pizza Hunters App brought me to Mr Dinos in Montair. As always the case in Montclair, you need to get lucky with Parking. Customer Service was excellent and owner was more than willing to talk about Pizza or anything else for that matter. Just a great local Pizzeria that has been around since the 80s. Pizza was solid, people were great, deserves a return Visit for sure.
Awesome food I like the penne vodka they have. If you are at Montclair NJ you need to check it out mmmmm
Having a large pie straight out of the oven, I'd expect a somewhat crispier crust, but it was incredibly doughy, the cheese and sauce were flavorful though, but the cheese was oozing everywhere. Feels like it was taken out of the oven too soon. The guy making the pizza gave me strong Uncle Jun' vibes, attitude and thick rimmed glasses and all. Not sure I would be coming back!
We’ve been coming here for over 15 years. (Well it’s different owners now.) And where the food is ok I find myself saying never again. Myself and son were walking by and smelled pizza. We hadn’t had lunch yet so in we went. I ordered two margarita slices for him. And one square vodka slice for me. $14!!!! More for a credit card purchase. (Still don’t get that.) I almost fell over. I know I know. It’s “speciality”
slices. And I know I know. It’s Montclair. And the economy. 
But come on. That’s nuts. There are other places around where you can get a whole pie for close to the same amount. And the pizza is better. I didn’t want to disappoint my son so I coughed up the money. But. Never. Again.
Superb New Jersey pizza by the slice shop. Traditional slice is outstanding and the Sicilian is worth checking out as well. Look forward to trying again when back in town. Great folks running this spot - spoke with Nick who was super friendly and cordial. Highly recommend folks stop by to try a slice.
Scouting for the Pizza Hunters App brought me to Mr Dinos in Montair. As always the case in Montclair, you need to get lucky with Parking. Customer Service was excellent and owner was more than willing to talk about Pizza or anything else for that matter. Just a great local Pizzeria that has been around since the 80s. Pizza was solid, people were great, deserves a return Visit for sure.
Awesome food I like the penne vodka they have. If you are at Montclair NJ you need to check it out mmmmm
Having a large pie straight out of the oven, I'd expect a somewhat crispier crust, but it was incredibly doughy, the cheese and sauce were flavorful though, but the cheese was oozing everywhere. Feels like it was taken out of the oven too soon. The guy making the pizza gave me strong Uncle Jun' vibes, attitude and thick rimmed glasses and all. Not sure I would be coming back!
We’ve been coming here for over 15 years. (Well it’s different owners now.) And where the food is ok I find myself saying never again. Myself and son were walking by and smelled pizza. We hadn’t had lunch yet so in we went. I ordered two margarita slices for him. And one square vodka slice for me. $14!!!! More for a credit card purchase. (Still don’t get that.) I almost fell over. I know I know. It’s “speciality”
slices. And I know I know. It’s Montclair. And the economy. 
But come on. That’s nuts. There are other places around where you can get a whole pie for close to the same amount. And the pizza is better. I didn’t want to disappoint my son so I coughed up the money. But. Never. Again.
Superb New Jersey pizza by the slice shop. Traditional slice is outstanding and the Sicilian is worth checking out as well. Look forward to trying again when back in town. Great folks running this spot - spoke with Nick who was super friendly and cordial. Highly recommend folks stop by to try a slice.
Scouting for the Pizza Hunters App brought me to Mr Dinos in Montair. As always the case in Montclair, you need to get lucky with Parking. Customer Service was excellent and owner was more than willing to talk about Pizza or anything else for that matter. Just a great local Pizzeria that has been around since the 80s. Pizza was solid, people were great, deserves a return Visit for sure.